Solar Power: Difference between revisions

From Space Exploration
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Templar4522
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Powering your structures with solar panels is something very common in Space Exploration. However, once you leave [[Nauvis]], it is not immediately obvious what the generated power will be and how to set up structures to meet your needs.
Solar power is a great way to provide electricity for your base without needing to worry about boilers or nuclear reactors running out of fuel, or pollution causing biter attacks. Powering your structures with solar panels is very common in Space Exploration, but once you leave [[Nauvis]] it is not immediately obvious how to generate power and how to set up structures to meet your needs.


Space Exploration not only adds additional solar panels and accumulators, but makes use of the game engine to give uniqueness to every location in game.
Space Exploration not only adds additional tiers of solar panels and accumulators, but makes use of the game engine to give uniqueness to every location in game.


Each surface has its own characteristics, and there are two that are relevant to solar power: day/night cycle duration, and solar efficiency.
Each surface has its own characteristics, and there are two that are relevant to solar power: day/night cycle duration, and solar efficiency.


On top of that, harnessing solar energy in space is easier to manage: space surfaces do not have nights, and always have 50% brightness, so instead of generating a variable amount of power depending on the time of the day, they will always generate a constant output.
Harnessing solar energy in space is easier to manage than the surface of a planet or moon. [[Space surface|Space surfaces]] do not have a day/night cycle.  They always have specific brightness relative to distance from a star, so instead of generating a variable amount of power depending on the time of the day, they will always generate a constant output.


Note: [[Nauvis]] always has 100% efficiency and the vanilla day/night cycle duration.
Note: [[Nauvis]] always has 100% efficiency and the vanilla day/night cycle duration.


Solar energy is also the first way of powering personal equipment in your armor's equipment grid, and is especially effective for armors worn in space.


 
==Structures & Equipment==
= Structures =
<div style="column-count:2">
 
=== Solar Panels ===
=== Solar Panels ===


Line 26: Line 26:
|-
|-
| Flat Solar Panel 3 || 1600 kW
| Flat Solar Panel 3 || 1600 kW
|-
| Portable Solar Panel || 30 kW
|}
|}


Line 32: Line 34:
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|-
|-
! Item !! Capacity
! Item !! Capacity !! Charge Rate !! Discharge Rate
|-
|-
| Accumulator || 5 MJ
| Accumulator || 5 MJ || 0.25MW || 0.5MW
|-
|-
| Holmium Accumulator || 50 MJ
| Holmium Accumulator || 50 MJ || 0.5MW || 5MW
|-
|-
| Naquium Accumulator || 250 MJ
| Naquium Accumulator || 250 MJ || 2.5MW || 25MW
|-
| Personal Battery || 20 MJ
|-
| Personal Battery Mk2 || 100 MJ
|}
|}
</div>


= Solar Power on Planet Surfaces =
==Solar Power on Planet Surfaces==


== Calculating the Accumulator/Panel Ratio ==
===Calculating the Accumulator/Panel Ratio===


The ratio formula is:
The ratio formula is:


<code>R = 0.168 * (MaxPanelOutput kW / AccumulatorCapacity kJ) * CycleDuration s * Efficiency / 100</code>
<code>R = 0.168 * (MaxPanelOutput kW / AccumulatorCapacity kJ) * CycleDuration s * (Efficiency / 100)</code>


Which, if using the vanilla panels and accumulators, can be further simplified into this:
Which, if using the vanilla panels and accumulators, can be further simplified into this:


<code>R = 0.002016 * CycleDuration s * Efficiency / 100</code>
<code>R = 0.002016 * CycleDuration s * (Efficiency / 100)</code>


Note the measurement units.
Note the measurement units.
Line 62: Line 69:


<code>
<code>
R = 0.168 * (60 kW / 5000 kJ) * 540 s * 120 / 100
R = 0.168 * (60 kW / 5000 kJ) * 540 s * (120 / 100)


R = 0.002016 * 540 s * 1.2
R = 0.002016 * 540 s * 1.2
Line 70: Line 77:
So when on planet Efficient's surface, we'd have to place roughly 13 accumulators every 10 solar panels.
So when on planet Efficient's surface, we'd have to place roughly 13 accumulators every 10 solar panels.


The high efficiency make it so that we need a smaller number of panels to power the base, but the very long day/night cycle requires many more accumulators to store the charge necessary to last the night.
With the high efficiency, we need a smaller number of panels to power the base, but the very long day/night cycle requires many more accumulators to store the charge necessary to last the night.


== Calculating the Average Panel Output ==
===Calculating the Average Panel Output===


This is easy to calculate:
This is easy to calculate:


<code>AveragePanelOutput = MaxPanelOutput * 0.7 * Efficiency / 100</code>
<code>AveragePanelOutput = MaxPanelOutput * 0.7 * (Efficiency / 100)</code>


The 0.7 constant is applied like in the vanilla game, as the equivalent time of a panel operating at average output is always 70% of a day cycle.
The 0.7 constant is applied like in the vanilla game, as the equivalent time of a panel operating at average output is always 70% of a day cycle.


===== Example: =====
=====Example:=====


Let's go back to planet Efficient. Having 120% efficiency, our average output for a vanilla panel would be:
Let's go back to planet Efficient. Having 120% efficiency, our average output for a vanilla panel would be:


<code>AveragePanelOutput = 60 kW * 0.7 * 120 / 100 = 50.4 kW</code>
<code>AveragePanelOutput = 60 kW * 0.7 * (120 / 100) = 50.4 kW</code>


== Comparing Planets ==
===Comparing Planets===


Given the same efficiency or similar day/night cycle, it's easy to tell which planet is better for solar. However, what if both characteristics are very different or very similar?
Given the same efficiency or similar day/night cycle, it's easy to tell which planet is better for solar. However, what if both characteristics are very different or very similar?


Efficiency at first might seem the most important trait, because with more power, the less items one needs, however if the day/night cycle is long enough, the accumulators might actually make things more expensive.
Efficiency at first might seem the most important trait, because with more power, the fewer buildings one needs.  But if the day/night cycle is long enough, the accumulators might actually make things more expensive.


Planet Efficient from the previous examples is actually slightly worse than Nauvis despite the higher efficiency. To generate 4.2 MW, Nauvis requires 100 solar panels and 84 accumulators, while Efficient requires 83.33 panels and 108.33 accumulators.
Planet Efficient from the previous examples is actually slightly worse than Nauvis despite the higher efficiency. To generate 4.2 MW, Nauvis requires 100 solar panels and 84 accumulators, while Efficient requires 83.33 panels and 108.33 accumulators.
Line 96: Line 103:
How not to get tricked then? It's easy. Take the day/night cycle length and divide it by the efficiency. The planet with the lower number wins.
How not to get tricked then? It's easy. Take the day/night cycle length and divide it by the efficiency. The planet with the lower number wins.


= Solar power in space =
==Solar power in space==


In space there is no day/night cycle, so there is no need to calculate ratios or average outputs, as panels will have a constant output and won't need to supply power to accumulators for the night.
In space there is no day/night cycle, so there is no need to calculate ratios or average outputs, as panels will have a constant output and won't need to supply power to accumulators for the night.


This constant output is calculated as usual by multiplying the nominal maximum output by the efficiency ratio (MaxPowerOutput * Efficiency / 100).
This constant output is calculated as usual by multiplying the nominal maximum output in [[Universe Explorer]] by the efficiency ratio (MaxPowerOutput * Efficiency / 100).


Note that this already takes into account the fact that in space there is a constant 50% brightness, so this calculated amount is actually 50% of what the game will show as maximum when checking the panel output, and the bonus will different from the efficiency percentage shown in the universe explorer - this is different from what you see planetside where the bonus shown is actually the efficiency percentage minus a hundred.
Note: the mouse-over text will display a bonus which is 2x the actual. This is to compensate for some internal script requirements (apparently space surfaces are perpetually at dusk, causing solar panels to have 50% effectiveness. Their efficiency is then doubled to compensate).


= See Also =
==See Also==


You can enter the rabbit hole of solar power calculation from the official Factorio wiki by clicking [https://wiki.factorio.com/Power_production#Solar_panels_and_accumulators here]
You can enter the rabbit hole of solar power calculation from the official Factorio wiki by clicking [https://wiki.factorio.com/Power_production#Solar_panels_and_accumulators here]
{{Template:MechanicsNav}}

Latest revision as of 11:58, 13 July 2024

Solar power is a great way to provide electricity for your base without needing to worry about boilers or nuclear reactors running out of fuel, or pollution causing biter attacks. Powering your structures with solar panels is very common in Space Exploration, but once you leave Nauvis it is not immediately obvious how to generate power and how to set up structures to meet your needs.

Space Exploration not only adds additional tiers of solar panels and accumulators, but makes use of the game engine to give uniqueness to every location in game.

Each surface has its own characteristics, and there are two that are relevant to solar power: day/night cycle duration, and solar efficiency.

Harnessing solar energy in space is easier to manage than the surface of a planet or moon. Space surfaces do not have a day/night cycle. They always have specific brightness relative to distance from a star, so instead of generating a variable amount of power depending on the time of the day, they will always generate a constant output.

Note: Nauvis always has 100% efficiency and the vanilla day/night cycle duration.

Solar energy is also the first way of powering personal equipment in your armor's equipment grid, and is especially effective for armors worn in space.

Structures & Equipment

Solar Panels

Item Maximum Power Output
Solar Panel 60 kW
Flat Solar Panel 400 kW
Flat Solar Panel 2 800 kW
Flat Solar Panel 3 1600 kW
Portable Solar Panel 30 kW

Accumulators

Item Capacity Charge Rate Discharge Rate
Accumulator 5 MJ 0.25MW 0.5MW
Holmium Accumulator 50 MJ 0.5MW 5MW
Naquium Accumulator 250 MJ 2.5MW 25MW
Personal Battery 20 MJ
Personal Battery Mk2 100 MJ

Solar Power on Planet Surfaces

Calculating the Accumulator/Panel Ratio

The ratio formula is:

R = 0.168 * (MaxPanelOutput kW / AccumulatorCapacity kJ) * CycleDuration s * (Efficiency / 100)

Which, if using the vanilla panels and accumulators, can be further simplified into this:

R = 0.002016 * CycleDuration s * (Efficiency / 100)

Note the measurement units.

Example:

The planet Efficient has 120% solar efficiency and 9 minutes day/night cycle.

If we want to know the ratio of vanilla accumulators per vanilla panels, we have:

R = 0.168 * (60 kW / 5000 kJ) * 540 s * (120 / 100)

R = 0.002016 * 540 s * 1.2

R = 1.3

So when on planet Efficient's surface, we'd have to place roughly 13 accumulators every 10 solar panels.

With the high efficiency, we need a smaller number of panels to power the base, but the very long day/night cycle requires many more accumulators to store the charge necessary to last the night.

Calculating the Average Panel Output

This is easy to calculate:

AveragePanelOutput = MaxPanelOutput * 0.7 * (Efficiency / 100)

The 0.7 constant is applied like in the vanilla game, as the equivalent time of a panel operating at average output is always 70% of a day cycle.

Example:

Let's go back to planet Efficient. Having 120% efficiency, our average output for a vanilla panel would be:

AveragePanelOutput = 60 kW * 0.7 * (120 / 100) = 50.4 kW

Comparing Planets

Given the same efficiency or similar day/night cycle, it's easy to tell which planet is better for solar. However, what if both characteristics are very different or very similar?

Efficiency at first might seem the most important trait, because with more power, the fewer buildings one needs. But if the day/night cycle is long enough, the accumulators might actually make things more expensive.

Planet Efficient from the previous examples is actually slightly worse than Nauvis despite the higher efficiency. To generate 4.2 MW, Nauvis requires 100 solar panels and 84 accumulators, while Efficient requires 83.33 panels and 108.33 accumulators.

How not to get tricked then? It's easy. Take the day/night cycle length and divide it by the efficiency. The planet with the lower number wins.

Solar power in space

In space there is no day/night cycle, so there is no need to calculate ratios or average outputs, as panels will have a constant output and won't need to supply power to accumulators for the night.

This constant output is calculated as usual by multiplying the nominal maximum output in Universe Explorer by the efficiency ratio (MaxPowerOutput * Efficiency / 100).

Note: the mouse-over text will display a bonus which is 2x the actual. This is to compensate for some internal script requirements (apparently space surfaces are perpetually at dusk, causing solar panels to have 50% effectiveness. Their efficiency is then doubled to compensate).

See Also

You can enter the rabbit hole of solar power calculation from the official Factorio wiki by clicking here