Rocket fuel from water (technology): Difference between revisions

From Space Exploration
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Kyralessa
Add details about recipe, including the fact that it doesn't produce "free energy" due to the energy cost of the fuel refinery.
imported>Kyralessa
More math to show when this formula makes sense to use, and when it doesn't.
Line 1: Line 1:
The [[Rocket fuel from water (technology)|rocket fuel from water]] recipe allows production of rocket fuel without oil production or pyroflux.
The [[Rocket fuel from water (technology)|rocket fuel from water]] recipe allows production of [[Solid rocket fuel|solid rocket fuel]] without [[Crude oil|oil]] production or [[Pyroflux|pyroflux]].


With this technology, [[Solid rocket fuel|solid rocket fuel]] can be created in a [[Fuel refinery|fuel refinery]] using only [[Water|water]] and 1 [[Copper plate|copper plate]].
With this technology, rocket fuel can be created in a [[Fuel refinery|fuel refinery]] using only 1000 [[Water|water]] and 1 [[Copper plate|copper plate]].


Although the ingredients are inexpensive, this isn't a "free energy" recipe.
==Energy efficiency==
 
You might wonder: Can you use this formula to get "free energy" by producing and burning the rocket fuel?


A fuel refinery consumes 1.03 megawatts of power.  In the 500 seconds required to make one rocket fuel, it consumes 515 megajoules, whereas a solid rocket fuel only contains 100 megajoules of power.
A fuel refinery consumes 1.03 megawatts of power.  In the 500 seconds required to make one rocket fuel, it consumes 515 megajoules, whereas a solid rocket fuel only contains 100 megajoules of power.


Even if [[Efficiency module (technology)|efficiency modules]] are used to reduce the fuel refinery's power to 20%, it still consumes 233.33 kilowatts, which causes it to consume 116 megajoules in 500 seconds, 16% more energy than the resulting solid rocket fuel yields.
What if [[Efficiency module (technology)|efficiency modules]] are used to reduce the fuel refinery's power by 80%?
 
A Joule is a [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joule#Definition watt-second].  At 80% energy reduction, a fuel refinery uses 233.33 kilowatts, or 233,330 watts, and this recipe takes 500 seconds.  233,330 * 500 = 116,665,000 Joules, or 116.665 megajoules.  As solid rocket fuel yields only 100 megajoules of energy, each solid rocket fuel costs nearly 17% more energy than it produces.  So while this formula can allow you to convert excess energy to solid rocket fuel in the absence of crude oil, it's energy-negative: it always costs more energy than it produces.  (By comparison, when using the standard solid rocket fuel formula with a reduced-power fuel refinery, 1 solid rocket fuel takes 1 second to produce, using 0.23333 megajoules of energy to produce 100 megajoules of solid rocket fuel, a nearly 430x increase in energy.)
 
==Cargo efficiency==
 
1 cargo rocket space can hold 10 rocket fuel, 100 [[Copper plate|copper plates]], or 50 [[Copper ingot|copper ingots]] (=500 copper plates).  Sending copper ingots and using rocket fuel from water is thus 500 times as '''cargo'''-efficient as sending rocket fuel by rocket ''if you have sufficient energy and water at your destination''.
 
What if you're going to a waterless planet?
 
[[Water barrel|Water barrels]] stack to 10, and a water barrel holds 50 water, so you can fit 500 water in a space.  As the recipe requires 1000 water per rocket fuel, it would take 2 cargo spaces to hold the water for a single rocket fuel when shipping with barrels.  Instead of 1 cargo space, copper and water barrels for 10 rocket fuel would take 21 cargo spaces!
 
[[Water ice]], however, stacks to 200, and requires no additional ingredients (but only machines) to convert to water.  Each water ice becomes 100 water, so 1 cargo rocket space holds 20,000 water, enough for 20 rocket fuel.  In this way, 1 stack of copper ingots (=500 copper plates) would require 25 stacks of water ice to produce 500 rocket fuel with this recipe.  This would use 26 spaces, vs. 50 spaces to transport 500 rocket fuel.
 
Therefore even when targeting a waterless planet, sending copper ingots and water ice to produce rocket fuel is roughly twice as cargo-efficient as shipping finished rocket fuel ''if you have sufficient energy production at the destination''.


{{Infobox SE
{{Infobox SE

Revision as of 14:21, 5 May 2024

The rocket fuel from water recipe allows production of solid rocket fuel without oil production or pyroflux.

With this technology, rocket fuel can be created in a fuel refinery using only 1000 water and 1 copper plate.

Energy efficiency

You might wonder: Can you use this formula to get "free energy" by producing and burning the rocket fuel?

A fuel refinery consumes 1.03 megawatts of power. In the 500 seconds required to make one rocket fuel, it consumes 515 megajoules, whereas a solid rocket fuel only contains 100 megajoules of power.

What if efficiency modules are used to reduce the fuel refinery's power by 80%?

A Joule is a watt-second. At 80% energy reduction, a fuel refinery uses 233.33 kilowatts, or 233,330 watts, and this recipe takes 500 seconds. 233,330 * 500 = 116,665,000 Joules, or 116.665 megajoules. As solid rocket fuel yields only 100 megajoules of energy, each solid rocket fuel costs nearly 17% more energy than it produces. So while this formula can allow you to convert excess energy to solid rocket fuel in the absence of crude oil, it's energy-negative: it always costs more energy than it produces. (By comparison, when using the standard solid rocket fuel formula with a reduced-power fuel refinery, 1 solid rocket fuel takes 1 second to produce, using 0.23333 megajoules of energy to produce 100 megajoules of solid rocket fuel, a nearly 430x increase in energy.)

Cargo efficiency

1 cargo rocket space can hold 10 rocket fuel, 100 copper plates, or 50 copper ingots (=500 copper plates). Sending copper ingots and using rocket fuel from water is thus 500 times as cargo-efficient as sending rocket fuel by rocket if you have sufficient energy and water at your destination.

What if you're going to a waterless planet?

Water barrels stack to 10, and a water barrel holds 50 water, so you can fit 500 water in a space. As the recipe requires 1000 water per rocket fuel, it would take 2 cargo spaces to hold the water for a single rocket fuel when shipping with barrels. Instead of 1 cargo space, copper and water barrels for 10 rocket fuel would take 21 cargo spaces!

Water ice, however, stacks to 200, and requires no additional ingredients (but only machines) to convert to water. Each water ice becomes 100 water, so 1 cargo rocket space holds 20,000 water, enough for 20 rocket fuel. In this way, 1 stack of copper ingots (=500 copper plates) would require 25 stacks of water ice to produce 500 rocket fuel with this recipe. This would use 26 spaces, vs. 50 spaces to transport 500 rocket fuel.

Therefore even when targeting a waterless planet, sending copper ingots and water ice to produce rocket fuel is roughly twice as cargo-efficient as shipping finished rocket fuel if you have sufficient energy production at the destination.


Rocket fuel from water (technology)

Cost

1
1
1
✖ 500

Required technologies

Effects